Did the coming up of robo-advisor services influences mutual funds in Japan?

Did the coming up of robo-advisor services influences mutual funds in Japan?

What are the user trends of robo-advisor services, such as Wealth Navi, Raku Wrap, and folio? This article investigates the changes in user size of robo-advisor services compared to mutual funds and the differences in user demographics by service in Japan.


In recent years, various investments such as virtual currencies, NISA, and IDECO have attracted attention. While some people have an image that investing is “too difficult for beginners”, robo-advisors are a service that even beginners can easily start investing.

Robo-advisors are services that provide users with asset management advice and assistance based on AI and expert analysis. There are two types of robo-advisors: “advice type” and “discretionary investment type”. In the “advice type”, the advisor suggests the optimal portfolio for the user's objectives, and the users make the final decision on their own. In the “discretionary investment type”, on the other hand, as long as you have the funds to invest, the company will handle everything from proposal to actual investment management.

In this study, we analyzed the robo-advisor market using “Dockpit”, an online activity log analysis tool from Values that enables users to analyze competitor sites and conduct trend research with a browser at hand, using activity log data that is updated monthly.

How many people are interested in robo-advisors? Comparison with mutual funds

First, let’s compare the number of users searching for “robo-advisor” with “mutual fund”.

The change in the number of search users is shown below.

Trend of users searching for “robo-advisor”

Trend of users searching for “robo-advisor”

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

Trend of users searching for “mutual fund”

Trend of users searching for “mutual fund”

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

Comparing the number of search users, “robo-advisor” is one order of magnitude smaller than “mutual fund” and is still a developing market. In addition, while “mutual fund” has nearly doubled the number of users from April 2020 to January 2022, “robo-advisor” has seen a steady decline overall, decreasing by 1/3 over the same period.

Next is a list of crosswords for “robo-advisor”.

Crossword list of searches for “robo-advisor”

Crossword list of searches for “robo-advisor”

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

The most common word in “robo-advisor” searches is “comparison”, which shows the behavior of considering which service to use.

On the other hand, “not recommended” and “disadvantages” were the words used to express negative concerns about robo-advisors. This may be due to the worries of using AI and other machines to select investment options. The words “reputation” and “actual results” were also seen, indicating that users are cautious about robo-advisors.

Next, we compared the user attributes. Let's look at the differences in gender and age.

Attributes of “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” search users: gender

Attributes of “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” search users: gender

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

Attributes of “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” search users: age

Attributes of “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” search users: age

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

There were no differences in gender and age attributes between “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” searchers. The majority of searchers by gender were males, and the volume zone by age were in their 30s.

Let's take a look at the annual household income composition.

Attributes of “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” search users: annual household income

Attributes of “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” search users: annual household income

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

There was also no significant difference between “mutual fund” and “robo-advisor” searchers in annual household income composition. Compared to all internet users, we can see that interests were higher from those with relatively high annual incomes.

In terms of the number of search users and the list of crosswords, it can be said that awareness of the robo-advisor market was not that high. However, the target market of robo-advisor is not so different from that of mutual fund, and if trust in robo-advisors increases in the future, there is a possibility that the number of users will explode.

The state of the market for robo-advisor services as seen by competitive analysis

We then analyzed the market for robo-advisors by comparing the number of website users for each service.

First, the table below compares the number of users of the websites of the three “advice type” services, Investment Trust Kobo, Monex Advisor, and SMBC Robo-advisor, by the use of Dockpit.

Comparison of the number of users of “advice type” robo-advisor services

Comparison of the number of users of “advice type” robo-advisor services

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

Investment Trust Kobo, operated by Matsui Securities, had the largest number of users at 110,000, followed by SMBC Robo-advisor and Monex Advisor, which was slightly behind the top two.

On the other hand, the table below compares the number of users of “discretionary investment type” services.

Comparison of the number of users of “discretionary investment” robo-advisor services

Comparison of the number of users of “discretionary investment” robo-advisor services

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

Wealth Navi, which had the largest number of users, having 6.91 million users in the two years from December 2019 to January 2022. Daiwa Fund Wrap Online also had 1 million users. Overall, it seems that there were much more users interested in the “discretionary investment type” services. If people are going to use robo-advisor services instead of mutual funds, many of them are likely to use the “discretionary investment type”, which allow them to leave everything to the services.

Let's take a look at the trend of users of “discretionary investment type” robo-advisor services over the past two years.

Trend of users of “discretionary investment type” robo-advisor services

Trend of users of “discretionary investment type” robo-advisor services

Period: December 2019 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

Wealth Navi was still the most popular site throughout the period, and susten and folio had also increased recently. Susten's explosive increase is thought to be due to the acquisition of users through some sort of promotional campaigns. However, there was also a sharp drop immediately after the increase. It shows that the campaigns might not lead to a stable inflow of users.

What kind of people are Wealth Navi users?

At last, we analyzed Wealth Navi, which has the largest number of users among robo-advisor services. Let's take a look at the interest map.

Interest map of Wealth Navi site visitors

Interest map of Wealth Navi site visitors

Period: February 2021 - January 2022
Devices: PCs and smartphones

The above map is calculated based on the following definitions with “reach rate” on the vertical axis and “feature value” on the horizontal axis.

Reach rate
Percentage of the targets who responded to the relevant item in the questionnaire.
Feature value

Indicator to visualize the genres of interest that the targets are characteristically interested in compared to the general internet users.Calculated as

(Reach rate of the target population) - (Reach rate of the entire online population)

The vertical axis is the “reach rate”; the higher the number, the greater the number of users interested in the genre. The horizontal axis is the “feature value”, which is a value that is higher for genres that the level of interests is markedly different from that of general internet users. Considering both values together, the genres located in the upper right corner of the graph are genres with unique interests and concerns of Wealth Navi users.

First, of course, interest in “money and investment” is by far the highest. Next are “economy”, “digital devices”, and “business-related”, which suggests interests in business in general and gadgets in particular. Incidentally, “real estate investment” and “deregulation of electricity” also follow, suggesting that the users are interested in efficient management of their assets.

Other relatively interesting topics include “outdoor activities”, “cars”, “photography / camera”, and “sports”. This suggests that some Wealth Navi users like to go outside and enjoy leisure activities such as outdoor activities and sports, and are also a little interested in cameras for taking pictures.

Summary

In this study, we compared the overall market for robo-advisor services with mutual funds, and then compared and analyzed “advice type” and “discretionary investment type” services, respectively. While the number of search users for mutual fund was increasing, the number of searchers for robo-advisor services was on a steady decline. We also found that some users are turning a cautious eye toward robo-advisors.

In the analysis of each service, more users were interested in the “discretionary investment type” than the “advice type”, when Wealth Navi attracted a large number of users among them.

About Dockpit

The data in this investigation is from Dockpit, an analytics tool with online behavior log data and user demographic information under the permission of panelists in Japan presented by VALUES, Inc.

※The numbers of users are estimated by the data in the monitor and the internet population in Japan.

dockpit Get free version

※日本語での記事はこちらをご確認ください

投資のロボアドバイザーサービスの利用者はどんな人?Web行動ログで調査

https://manamina.valuesccg.com/articles/1677

ウェルスナビや楽ラップ、folioをはじめとしたロボアドバイザーサービスのユーザー動向とは。本記事では投資信託と比較したロボアドバイザーサービスのユーザー規模の変化や、サービスごとのユーザー属性の違いについて調査します。

この記事のライター

マナミナは" まなべるみんなのデータマーケティング・マガジン "。
市場の動向や消費者の気持ちをデータを調査して伝えます。

編集部は、メディア出身者やデータ分析プロジェクト経験者、マーケティングコンサルタント、広告代理店出身者まで、様々なバックグラウンドのメンバーが集まりました。イメージは「仲の良いパートナー会社の人」。難しいことも簡単に、「みんながまなべる」メディアをめざして、日々情報を発信しています。

関連する投稿


2023年の「母の日」のトレンドを予測!定番の「花」以外に伸びている需要とは?

2023年の「母の日」のトレンドを予測!定番の「花」以外に伸びている需要とは?

来年の「母の日」に向けて、今年や昨年のデータから近年のニーズを考察し、最近のトレンドや2023年にどんなギフトが流行りそうかについて調査・分析します。母の日に向けた企画やプロモーション検討の参考になれば幸いです。


みんなが気にしているのは何のデメリット?おすすめ情報が気になるものとは?

みんなが気にしているのは何のデメリット?おすすめ情報が気になるものとは?

インターネットで何かを調べるとき、慎重な人はメリットよりデメリットが気になりますよね。または、インターネット上のおすすめ情報にも敏感な人は多いと思います。 今回の調査は、デメリットやおすすめ情報を調べる人の特性について、どんなジャンルで検索されているかも含めて分析していきます。


みんなはどんなプチプラアイテムを買っている?支持される「プチプラ」の特徴と傾向を分析

みんなはどんなプチプラアイテムを買っている?支持される「プチプラ」の特徴と傾向を分析

さまざまなものが値上がりしている2022年。いま、世間ではリーズナブルな価格をコンセプトとする「プチプラ」商品への関心が高まっています。今回は1年を通してどのような「プチプラ」へのニーズがあるのか、ヴァリューズのWeb行動ログ分析ツール「Dockpit」のデータをもとに検証しました。


Manga app case study: Number of users & demographics among growing manga apps

Manga app case study: Number of users & demographics among growing manga apps

A look into the number of manga app users over the two-year period starting September 2020 shows remarkable growth, perhaps due in part to the COVID-19 stay-at-home. Here, we examine "LINE Manga," "Piccoma," "Shonen Jump+ (Shueisha)," "Magapoke (Kodansha)" and "Manga One (Shogakukan)."


独自の競合サイト分析やキーワード分析ができる、Dockpitとは?~ Dockpitならではの機能やデータ特徴を解説

独自の競合サイト分析やキーワード分析ができる、Dockpitとは?~ Dockpitならではの機能やデータ特徴を解説

消費者ニーズが多様化する中、マーケティングの企画立案を進める上で、競合分析や消費者分析の重要性がより高まっています。Web行動ログ分析ツール「Dockpit(ドックピット)」では、消費者Web行動データを活用し、Web上の消費者行動を起点とした競合サイト分析や消費者分析が可能です。今回はDockpitならではの利便性の高い機能や活用方法を解説します。


最新の投稿


タイパとは?Z世代が重視する「タイパ至上主義」の背景とマーケティング事例

タイパとは?Z世代が重視する「タイパ至上主義」の背景とマーケティング事例

Z世代は、生活のあらゆる場面でタイパ(タイムパフォーマンス)を意識しています。「タイパ至上主義」という言葉が登場するほど、Z世代は時間効率を重視しているのです。この記事では、Z世代の購買心理・最新のトレンドを知るために、タイパの概要や価値観、マーケティング事例を解説します。


2022年中国の「独身の日=ダブルイレブン」商戦。最新のトレンド業界は?

2022年中国の「独身の日=ダブルイレブン」商戦。最新のトレンド業界は?

ダブルイレブン(W11)とは、毎年<b>11月11日に中国で行われている独身の日を祝うイベント</b>です。2022年のダブルイレブンでは、ECプラットフォームや店舗などの関係者が売上高を伸ばすことに力を入れていました。その中で加盟店が示す戦況報告からは、中国のマーケットで、新しい産業やブランドが急成長しているのを垣間見ることができます。 本記事では、2022年ダブルイレブンのトレンドとなった業界を中心にご紹介します。


Popular AI Image Generators, “Midjourney” and “Stable Diffusion.” Who are giving attention?

Popular AI Image Generators, “Midjourney” and “Stable Diffusion.” Who are giving attention?

We will investigate "Midjourney" and "Stable Diffusion" AI Image Generators, which allow anyone to generate images from keywords. Let’s look into it users, its purpose, the reason for its popularity, and its strengths. We will analyze the data of the interest group and analyze our user experience.


お菓子業界5社をマーケティング視点で企業研究! 大学生のデータドリブン就活|2022年最新版

お菓子業界5社をマーケティング視点で企業研究! 大学生のデータドリブン就活|2022年最新版

お菓子業界大手の「森永製菓」「江崎グリコ」「カルビー」「ブルボン」「不二家」。各公式サイトの集客状況に注目し、強みや施策の違いを調査します。2年半前に公開した同記事の最新版として、新たな発見をお届けします。


行動経済学の入門書籍20選!教科書や今人気のベストセラーも紹介

行動経済学の入門書籍20選!教科書や今人気のベストセラーも紹介

経済学に心理学を組み合わせる「行動経済学」。マーケティングとの親和性の高さ、そしてマーケティング活動のためのヒントがあるとされており、さまざまな場面で活用が進んでいます。行動経済学をビジネスに活かすには、そのエッセンスがよくまとまった本・書籍で学ぶのが近道です。今回は、ベストセラー本から教科書的なものまで、行動経済学についてまんべんなく学べるよう、20冊のおすすめ本を紹介します。


競合も、業界も、トレンドもわかる、マーケターのためのリサーチエンジン Dockpit 無料登録はこちら